Finding the perfect eyeliner is a bit like finding the right partner: it needs to stick by your side (or on your lids), come rain or shine. Over the past three months, I’ve embarked on a beauty journey, rigorously testing some of Sephora’s best-sellers to find you the top eyeliners under $30. Each of these picks has not only adorned my eyes but also passed the long-wear test, proving their worth. Whether you’re aiming for a dramatic cat-eye or a subtle everyday look, these liners promise to impress.

1. Creamy Kohl Longwear Eye Pencil by HUDA BEAUTY

This kohl pencil has been a game-changer in my makeup routine, offering rich pigment and a gloriously creamy texture that glides on like a dream. Its staying power is remarkable, surviving long days without smudging or fading. A top review says, “Absolutely unbeatable for the waterline! It’s the only eyeliner that doesn’t melt off my face by midday.”

2. Wink Stamp Original Waterproof Wing Eyeliner Stamp & Pen by KAJA

For those who struggle with achieving symmetrical wings, the KAJA Wink Stamp is your new best friend. The innovative stamp helps create the perfect wing in seconds, while the pen end fills in and defines the rest of the eyeliner. After three months of use, it’s still delivering a smudge-proof finish. A fan explains, “My wings have never been sharper or more symmetrical! Plus, it stays on through my entire 12-hour shift.”

3. DRAMA LIQUI-PENCIL™ Longwear Eyeliner by Lancôme

Lancôme’s DRAMA LIQUI-PENCIL™ offers the intensity of a liquid liner with the ease of a pencil. Its creamy formula ensures a smooth application, and the colors are vivid and impactful. “It glides on effortlessly and the color payoff is phenomenal. Best of all, it really lives up to its longwear name,” a reviewer notes.

4. They’re Real! Xtreme Precision Eye Liner by Benefit Cosmetics

Precision is the name of the game with this eyeliner. Its ultra-fine tip allows for meticulous application, perfect for crafting detailed and intricate eye looks. The formula is quick-drying and doesn’t budge. “Perfect for thin, precise lines, and the formula is a deep, matte black. It doesn’t fade or feather, even on my oily lids,” says a satisfied user.

5. 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil by Urban Decay

Urban Decay’s 24/7 liners are beloved for their vibrant color range and effortless application. The waterproof formula ensures that it stays put, no matter what. “I’ve cried, sweated, and even swam with this eyeliner on, and it didn’t move an inch. I can’t recommend it enough!” enthuses a loyal customer.

Why each eye-liner is unique in its own way?

Comparing these liners, each has its unique strengths: HUDA BEAUTY’s pencil excels in creaminess and blendability, perfect for smoky eyes. The KAJA stamp pen is unmatched for creating flawless wings effortlessly, ideal for beginners or those in a hurry. Lancôme’s pencil combines the dramatic impact of liquid liner with pencil convenience, making it versatile for both bold and fine lines. Benefit’s liner is the go-to for ultra-precision work, whereas Urban Decay offers the best color variety and all-day resilience. Choosing between them depends largely on your specific needs and the look you’re aiming for.

Conclusion

Each of these eyeliners offers unique benefits, but all promise long-lasting wear and undeniable quality. From HUDA’s creamy kohl to Urban Decay’s vibrant pencils, there’s something here for every style and occasion. I encourage you to pick up one (or more!) of these liners and see for yourself why they’ve become essentials in my beauty arsenal. Just remember, while beauty might be in the eye of the beholder, a great eyeliner in the hand is worth two in the bush!